There is a fierce battle on the ICC’s substitute rule. Rishabh Pant has been injured in the India vs England Manchester Test, there is a fracture in his toe, due to which he is under threat of being out of the series. Meanwhile, new rules have been implemented for replacement in first-class cricket. Now the rule has been made to replace the batsman and the bowler instead of the batsman. However, at present, this rule will be implemented only as a trial.

The rule of like for like replacement in first-class cricket will be implemented from October 2025. The player can be replaced if he gets a serious injury. The purpose of this rule will be to maintain fairness in the match, which does not harm the team whose player is injured.

This rule will be applicable only when the player is seriously injured. The new replacement rule will not be applicable in the event of problems like hamstring or mild pain. This rule of ICC also says that the player who came as a replacement will not take up all the responsibilities that the injured player was handling. That is, a full substitute cannot be replaced in place of the injured player.

A similar situation currently remains in India vs England Manchester Test, where the Indian team will suffer a huge loss due to the injury of Rishabh Pant. Pant had scored 37 runs before the injury in this match and was moving towards the big score. Let us know that Pant has scored more than 450 runs in the current series, so his injury is very bad news for Team India, because this new replacement rule is not applicable in Test cricket at the moment.

Also read:

Like Rishabh Pant, Steve Smith was also injured at the time of batting, Jofra Archer had ball; Then Labushen played in his place

Ind vs Eng: Who will replace Rishabh Pant? There are 3 contenders, not one or two; Will surprise the list

In the match number 16 of IPL 2025 against Lucknow Super Giants, Mumbai Indians used the retired out rule and called Tilak Verma out of the ground without being out. In place of them, the team sent Mitchell Santner to bat. Tilak was neither injured nor there was any reason that he was not able to bat, despite his team had the right to send them out and send them to the next batsman. Many people are considering retired outs as retired heart, but it is not so. Let’s know the difference between the two.

What is retired out? What is retired out?

When no batsman is out and is not injured, but he or his team wants any other batsman to come on the field, then retired out rules are used. Under this rule, the permission of the umpire is not required. Retired is written in front of the batsman’s name. The retired batsman cannot come back to bat in that match. However, if the umpire and the captain of the opposing team are allowed, then in that case the player can do the batsman.

The team uses this rule for its own benefit. When he feels that no batsman is in form and is unable to bat in important time, then the team sends another batsman using it in his place.

What is Retired Hurt? What is retired heart

There is a danger of the players being injured in cricket, there was a retired heart rule for this situation. Under this, if a player goes out of the field due to any injury or health related reasons, he is considered a retired heart. For this, the batsman or his team will have to get permission from the umpire. In this situation, if he becomes healthy for batting, then he will have the right to come on batting. For this, the captain of the opposing team will not be allowed.

Concussion Substitute: Rule of Concisition Substitute in Retired Heart

For example, on Saturday, Pakistan opener Imam ul Haq was injured, the ball was in his jaw. The medical team came and investigated them but could not get permission for batting back. In this situation, his Convention Substitute was announced. That is, another player was included in the playing 11 in his place. For this, the permission of the medical team is required, which tells that it is not safe for the batsman to play right now.

Retired Hurt vs Retired Out: What is the big difference between the two?

A big difference between retired heart and retired out is that retired heart occurs when the player is unable to bat for any injury or proper reason. While the retired out team or player’s will without any reasonable reason. In a retired heart, the batsman can come to bat when a wicket falls when he is healthy, but he cannot do so in a retired out. Here the captain of the opposing team has to decide whether he can bat or not.

On Friday, Tilak Verma was retired out and on Saturday, Pakistan opener Imam ul Haq retired. Within about 24 hours, we got to see both examples in cricket.